Two restaurants that complained when parking requirements were waived on Jeffersonville’s Riverside Drive did not have standing to challenge the city because they could not demonstrate monetary damages.
That’s according to an Indiana Court of Appeals decision issued Thursday in a suit involving a handful of businesses along Jeffersonville’s Restaurant Row.
The decision, which essentially sides with the city by dismissing the legal challenge, has been about three years in the making.
HOW IT STARTED
In 2006, a hotel management company called MHI Hospitality purchased what had been a Ramada Inn along Riverside Drive. The company remodeled and rebranded the hotel, turning it into a Sheraton.
The development was taking place across the street from two other restaurants that put down roots along Riverside Drive six years prior — Buckhead Mountain Grill and Rocky’s Italian Grill.
In late 2007, Jeffersonville’s Board of Zoning Appeals granted MHI a parking waiver, which allowed it to open a Bearno’s Pizza in what had been the Ramada Inn’s old Conference Room.
Shortly afterward, Buckhead and Rocky’s filed a lawsuit against the city and MHI alleging the parking waiver was injurious to public health and safety and would adversely affect the value of their property.
The trial court heard the case in October 2008 and affirmed the city’s variance.
THE DECISION
In the decision it issued Thursday, the appeals court cited state statute, noting that in order to have standing to seek judicial review of a zoning appeals decision, a person must be “aggrieved.”
“Here, there is no evidence that Buckhead and Rocky’s would suffer any monetary loss by the granting of the developmental standards variance,” the court says.
Even though Rocky’s and Buckhead claim that numerous customers of the businesses across the street park in their spots without consent, “they failed to assert how this harmed them monetarily,” the decision said.
REACTION
Attorneys from each side reacted to the decision Thursday.
“How someone using your property — without your consent — is not a burden is beyond me,” said Greg Fifer, who represented the restaurants.
He said the decision avoids the underlying issue — a lack of parking spaces — and instead is made on whether the restaurants had standing to make a complaint.
“I just think that this is a decision that’s absurd on its face,” Fifer said.
“That’s the standing issue,” said attorney Larry Wilder, who represented the city. “That person [making the complaint] has to show some potential damages.”
Wilder praised the decision, saying it was one that will allow growth to continue along Riverside Drive.
Fifer was unsure whether his clients were interested in petitioning the Indiana Supreme Court to hear the case, saying it has not yet been discussed.
He expects to make a decision on that matter within the next few days.
Business/Money
Related Photos
-
In 2007, Jeffersonville’s Board of Zoning Appeals granted MHI Hospitality — which owns the Sheraton along Riverside Drive — a parking waiver which allowed it to open a Bearno’s Pizza in what had been the Ramada Inn’s old Conference Room. By C.E. BRANHAM
Discussion
Court: Restaurants don’t have standing to challenge parking in Jeffersonville
Ruling says Buckhead, Rocky’s could not demonstrate losses
- Business/Money
-
-
River View gets a new option
As for progress, Bobo said he met with two banks Tuesday prior to the meeting. He added there’s been interest in financing the project from national lenders including U.S. Bank.
Additionally, Bobo said his team has meet with national investors as another source to fund the project and believes Mainland Properties could soon gain financial partners for River View. -
Bridges project specifics emerging
Valentine outlined that incentives will be part of Kentucky’s contract with the winning bidder.
He explained that once construction begins, the expected cost of construction per day will total about $80,000 and the contractor can earn incentives for finishing early and penalties for finishing late. A completion date is set for June 30, 2018. -
Spring Street Hill Road repair to begin around June 1
Councilman Bob Caesar, who sponsored the council measure and is a Silver Hills resident, said the reopening of Spring Street Hill road will be a “big deal” for the community.
“We just wanted to make sure this was done once and done right,” he said. -
TARC OKs rate increases
Contrary to its monetary situation, the amount of people riding the public transit system has increased about 10 percent, Barker said.
But the transportation service had not raised its fares, aside from express routes, in four years. -
Workshops on windows set for Thursday
Instructor Jack P. Patchin of Ol’ House Experts in Madison has more than 30 years of experience in construction and restoration. Patchin has restored wood windows for homes, barns, and outbuildings.
-
A bit less jump at the pump
Recent developments in the economic crisis in Greece and an apparent slowdown in China’s economy could be important to summer’s gasoline prices.
-
Jeffersonville budget cuts move forward
The action is not final, as officially the council has only approved a resolution instructing the city’s financial officer to advertise the cuts.
-
Corden Porter purchase tabled again
The council expressed other concerns, including the potential for asbestos in the building, the costs to cover utility payments and the costs to renovate the building.
-
Road work ahead: Projects under way in New Albany
The city earmarked about $600,000 of federal Community Development Block Grant funds to improve and install sidewalks. The project list, which has to focus on inner city areas because of CDBG regulations, is nearly finished, Rosenbarger said.
-
State takeover of failing schools meets resistance
Under the law, the state can step in and turn the failing school over to a private operator.
Seven schools in Indiana located in high-poverty school districts in Gary and Indianapolis are set to be taken over this coming school year. - More Business/Money Headlines
-
River View gets a new option
Beryl Makes Landfall on Florida Coast
UN Blames Syrian Forces for Shelling Houla
Raw Video: Gay Protest Blocked in Moscow
Vatican in Chaos After Butler Arrested for Leaks
Jimmy Carter Endorses Egypt's Election Results
Biden Addresses West Point Graduating Class
Dozens of Children Killed in New Syria Attack
Raw Video: Activists Allege Massacre in Syria
NJ Man Charged With Murder in Death of Patz
Support, Fun for Kids of Fallen Soldiers at Camp
Fugitive Penguin Caught, Returned to Aquarium
50 Years Later, Underground Fire Still Burning
Light Show Transforms Sydney Opera House
Raw Video: Unruly Passenger Restrained in Miami
Raw Video: Robber Uses Drive-thru Window
Raw Video: Dragon Arrives at Space Station
Calif.'s Coronado Named Nation's Best Beach
CEO Salaries Become Sore Issue in Labor Disputes
