Two restaurants that complained when parking requirements were waived on Jeffersonville’s Riverside Drive did not have standing to challenge the city because they could not demonstrate monetary damages.
That’s according to an Indiana Court of Appeals decision issued Thursday in a suit involving a handful of businesses along Jeffersonville’s Restaurant Row.
The decision, which essentially sides with the city by dismissing the legal challenge, has been about three years in the making.
HOW IT STARTED
In 2006, a hotel management company called MHI Hospitality purchased what had been a Ramada Inn along Riverside Drive. The company remodeled and rebranded the hotel, turning it into a Sheraton.
The development was taking place across the street from two other restaurants that put down roots along Riverside Drive six years prior — Buckhead Mountain Grill and Rocky’s Italian Grill.
In late 2007, Jeffersonville’s Board of Zoning Appeals granted MHI a parking waiver, which allowed it to open a Bearno’s Pizza in what had been the Ramada Inn’s old Conference Room.
Shortly afterward, Buckhead and Rocky’s filed a lawsuit against the city and MHI alleging the parking waiver was injurious to public health and safety and would adversely affect the value of their property.
The trial court heard the case in October 2008 and affirmed the city’s variance.
THE DECISION
In the decision it issued Thursday, the appeals court cited state statute, noting that in order to have standing to seek judicial review of a zoning appeals decision, a person must be “aggrieved.”
“Here, there is no evidence that Buckhead and Rocky’s would suffer any monetary loss by the granting of the developmental standards variance,” the court says.
Even though Rocky’s and Buckhead claim that numerous customers of the businesses across the street park in their spots without consent, “they failed to assert how this harmed them monetarily,” the decision said.
REACTION
Attorneys from each side reacted to the decision Thursday.
“How someone using your property — without your consent — is not a burden is beyond me,” said Greg Fifer, who represented the restaurants.
He said the decision avoids the underlying issue — a lack of parking spaces — and instead is made on whether the restaurants had standing to make a complaint.
“I just think that this is a decision that’s absurd on its face,” Fifer said.
“That’s the standing issue,” said attorney Larry Wilder, who represented the city. “That person [making the complaint] has to show some potential damages.”
Wilder praised the decision, saying it was one that will allow growth to continue along Riverside Drive.
Fifer was unsure whether his clients were interested in petitioning the Indiana Supreme Court to hear the case, saying it has not yet been discussed.
He expects to make a decision on that matter within the next few days.
Business/Money
Related Photos
-
In 2007, Jeffersonville’s Board of Zoning Appeals granted MHI Hospitality — which owns the Sheraton along Riverside Drive — a parking waiver which allowed it to open a Bearno’s Pizza in what had been the Ramada Inn’s old Conference Room. By C.E. BRANHAM
Discussion
Court: Restaurants don’t have standing to challenge parking in Jeffersonville
Ruling says Buckhead, Rocky’s could not demonstrate losses
- Business/Money
-
-
New Albany City Council will be asked to clarify audit issue over sewer rates
Several members from the audience also questioned other financial matters of the city, and whether the council was aware that Gibson received health insurance as city attorney under England though it had been stated by the previous administration his contract did not include medical benefits.
-
River Ridge moves forward with development plans
No sale has been finalized on either piece of land, as River Ridge owns the 16-acre parcel, and the adjacent 54-acre tract is owned by Crossdock Development, a Louisville-based company that specializes in developing properties on the order of millions of square feet.
-
Town has no cure for ailing medical center
-
First Savings buys bank branches
The move will increase First Savings’ market share in Harrison County to about 31 percent and up the bank’s presence in Floyd County.
-
Free falling: CCE demolishes former New Albany business at no charge
-
Paying their fair share?
John Gilkey, president of the town council, said when Knott initially shared the information with him a few weeks ago, he was surprised to learn some residents weren’t paying any taxes.
-
Neace Lukens acquires Jenkins Insurance of Sellersburg
Jenkins Insurance principal Mike Jenkins will join the Neace Lukens’ New Albany office, where he’ll focus on his current employee benefit clients and expanding service and product platforms for the company.
-
Some lawmakers want you to cruise in for Sunday commerce
The current ban on motorcycle sales is a remnant of Indiana’s old “blue laws” that prohibited various activities on Sundays. The legislature has been slowly chipping away at them.
-
Checkered past: Cab company’s permit suspended in New Albany after employee arrests
“We’re not an evil company,” White said after the meeting.
-
Jeffersonville mayor, council disagree on hiring
Moore said he would veto the legislation, but include a recommendation that the three already hired positions be funded. Zastawny said the council would consider that recommendation.
- More Business/Money Headlines
-
New Albany City Council will be asked to clarify audit issue over sewer rates
Obama Gives Education Waivers to 10 States
Giffords Aide to Run for Her Seat
LA School in Sex Abuse Scandal Reopens
Winter Slamming North Asia, Parts of Europe
Syrian Forces Renew Bombardment of Homs
States, Banks Reach Foreclosure-abuse Settlement
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
Greeks March; Angry Despite Debt Deal
Raw Video: U.S. Pullout Celebration
Raw Video: Annual Empire State Building Run-Up
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case
Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows
Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
