MARCUS: Individual responsibility leads to denial of charity

Related Photos

Discussion

September 16, 2009

By MORTON MARCUS The News and Tribune Wed Sep 16, 2009, 01:52 AM EDT

The Rev. Robert Rector is a prominent minister in our community. Recently, he asked me to meet him in a local dive.

As I entered the dimly lit bar, I could not find the clergyman dressed in black. Slowly, as my eyes adjusted to the haze of cigarette smoke, I found Rev. Bob in the corner, partly obscured by the juke box.

“Hi, Rev. Bob,” I said. He said nothing. “What gives?” I asked. He did not reply. “Why this place for a meeting?”

“Get a beer and sit down,” he growled.

I went to the bar and returned with my beer as instructed. Clearly, the good pastor was not in the mood for banter.

“Do you see what is happening in this country?” he asked.

“What?” I replied, knowing that whatever answer I offered would be unwelcome if it were not in agreement with his observation.

“We,” he said with that strong, stern voice I had heard so often from the pulpit, “are about to destroy sympathy and charity by insisting on personal responsibility in health maintenance.

“We are setting the stage for denying health care to folks we define as ‘sinners-against-self.’”

“I don’t understand,” I said because I did not understand. “I thought we achieved fairly universal agreement that everyone is entitled to health care. I haven’t heard anything about denying health care to anyone for any reason.”

“You fail to look deeply into the renewed Puritan morality being injected into health care,” Rev. Bob said. “The cult of insidious individualism is on the rise. Where once we believed people were victims of disease, we now insist that illness is a reflection of choices actively made.

“Instead of sickness being a passive state, our actions now are regarded as the determinants of our disorders.”

“You may be right,” I offered tentatively.

“I am right,” he asserted. “If you eat foods not on the ordained menu, your subsequent problems are your fault. If you smoke or drink, you are now beyond the new moral pale. Thus far we still operate under the old philosophy of communal concern for the sick, but those days are limited.

“In days to come, we will punish those who become ill as a result of their choices. We may charge them more for health care — as we now charge smokers more for health insurance — or we may defer their treatment, ultimately denying them the benefits of traditional medical assistance.

“Soon doctors turn from guidance to denunciation of those with ‘self-inflicted’ wounds. As our health care system becomes more and more one of fiscal entanglement — government or private — society demands that each person conform to the behavior dictated by contemporary medical thought. Let a study come forth that cucumbers are carcinogenic and eating pickles will be make one a social pariah.

“Verily, the day approaches when environmental harm will be blamed on those who are damaged because they ‘chose’ to put themselves in the way of documented danger.”

“You are being extreme,” I said harshly.

“I think not,” he exclaimed. “Just when we finally accept the principle of universal health care, we are simultaneously setting the foundation for a new fundamentalism of ‘responsibility’ that will allow us to reject and deny millions of people whose actions are not approved by the entrenched health establishment.”

Sadly, I rose and left. Rev. Bob is right. It would be tragic if we again treat illness — physical and mental — as we have treated poverty and ignorance — as self-imposed conditions — when illness, poverty and ignorance often are the consequences of choices made by those with the means and the power to prevent and alleviate such suffering.

Morton Marcus is an independent economist, speaker and writer formerly with IU’s Kelley School of Business. Reach him at mortonjmarcus@yahoo.com

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Business/Money

A checkup for the community: Assessment tells health story of Floyd, surrounding counties
This report is a compilation of health and quality of life indicators for Floyd County. The report indicates that in Floyd County cancers, heart disease, obesity and smoking are growing problems.

May 21, 2012
Rebuild Marysville event raises money for town hit by tornado
Kirsty Travelstead of Marysville explained that as of Saturday morning, more than 300 T-shirts had been sold. For the event they had hopes of raising at least $5,000 from the T-shirts, food sales and the grill raffle.

May 21, 2012 2 Photos
New Albany City Council defeats bridges resolution
But Gonder said residents, especially those from Southern Indiana, will be struck the hardest by an inflated project cost of $2.6 billion that relies on tolling.
“We wouldn’t be in this fix if we were only going to build the east-end bridge,” he said.

May 18, 2012 1 Photo
Local officials react to proposed TARC cuts
The fare increases will raise a one-way adult fare from $1.50 to $1.75 and a monthly pass would increase from $42 to $50. TARC has not raised its base fare since 2008. The proposed rates are in line with public transportation fares charged in Indianapolis and Cincinnati, where one-way adult fare is already $1.75.

May 18, 2012
Jeffersonville’s Victorian Chautauqua set for weekend
Part of the event’s success is due to the fact that it hasn’t become overgrown during the last two decades, she said. Further, exhibitors and entertainment are always well received.

May 18, 2012
A night of thanks: Lady Antebellum event raises $285,000 for Henryville
May 17, 2012 6 Photos
Accent shows off new facility in Jeffersonville
Wednesday’s event was a formality in most aspects, as the building has actually been open since late March. However, it did mark a significant milestone for the Jeffersonville Town Center — a proposed shopping development that has struggled to attract commercial growth in the many years it’s been planned on Jeffersonville’s Veterans Parkway.

May 17, 2012 1 Photo
Economy not out of the woods yet, economists say
“Last November, I thought I was very optimistic, we were seeing some positive growths,” Dufrene said. “But right now, I think the outlook is more uncertain.”

May 17, 2012 1 Photo
Floyd County preparing for busy road season
Recently, a void on the side of the payment was spotted at the top of Spickert Knob Road. The road was repaired and reopened last December.

May 16, 2012
Treasure hunt: Attorney General explains how to find unclaimed property
Unclaimed property includes investment earnings, insurance proceeds and benefits, wages and money from bank accounts. It does not include real estate, abandoned vehicles or other such items.

May 16, 2012
More Business/Money Headlines

Business/Money

Search Results

Related Photos

Discussion

MARCUS: Individual responsibility leads to denial of charity

Site Map

Contact Us