Embattled Clark Superior Court No. 1 Judge Jerome F. Jacobi took another hit late Monday afternoon when the husband of his primary election opponent sued him and supporter Jack Vissing for defamation of character.
Jeffersonville attorney Lonnie Cooper claims his “personal and professional reputations have been damaged” by comments Jacobi and Vissing made against him in defense of Jerry Lemmons, Jacobi’s former chief of staff.
Cooper is the husband of Jeffersonville City Court Judge Vicki Carmichael, who beat Jacobi by nearly 1,200 votes in Tuesday’s Democratic Party primary. Jacobi was elected to the bench in 1994 and again in 2000.
Cooper said he filed the suit in Clark Circuit Court at around 4:30 p.m. Monday. He said he tried to arrange the timing of the filing so that it would be almost impossible for news of the action to reach the media until after the election, something he said Carmichael insisted upon.
“It isn’t about the election,” Cooper said during a telephone interview Thursday. “I will only take so many shots to my integrity.”
A woman who answered the phone in Clark Superior Court No. 1 on Thursday said Jacobi will not return to the office until Monday.
During a telephone interview on Thursday afternoon, Vissing said he had not seen the suit but called it “incredible.”
“I always thought truth was a defense,” Vissing said.
Lemmons, who is either 71 or 81 depending on reports, resigned as Jacobi’s chief of staff Feb. 8, but is under investigation by Vanderburgh County Prosecutor Stan Levco. The investigation is the result of at least two former Clark Superior Court No. 1 employees accusing Lemmons of inappropriately receiving, handling and depositing fees collected; committing theft; engaging in ghost employment; and using public funds for personal purposes.
Levco is scheduled to meet with a special grand jury May 25 to seek indictments against one or more unnamed targets.
Cooper’s name has been associated with two issues that have surfaced as part of the investigation into Lemmons’ alleged behavior.
Last year, court funds were allegedly used to pay a $265 bill for baseball caps and T-shirts for Cooper’s campaign for sheriff. Cooper, who ultimately decided not to run in this year’s primary, eventually paid the bill himself after learning that court funds might have been utilized to pay for the campaign materials.
Cooper also served as an unpaid volunteer providing legal advice to a pair of not-for-profit corporations that had been established to support Teen Court, a program that has served more than 6,000 youths since Jacobi founded it. Vissing and Jacobi have made public claims that Cooper failed to properly advise Lemmons on bookkeeping matters, but Cooper contends he repeatedly recommended that Lemmons seek the advice of a certified public accountant.
Cooper said he believes Jacobi and Vissing have orchestrated their responses to questions from the public and media about Levco’s investigation of Lemmons in an effort to use Cooper to hurt Carmichael’s election bid.
“I think they have developed this in concert for their own personal and political gain,” Cooper said.
“I simply answered questions,” Vissing said. “I don’t see how I could have defamed him.”
In his suit, Cooper does not specify the damages he is seeking.
“If they don’t admit what they said is not true, I’ll take every dime I can,” Cooper said.
The law generally protects judges and lawyers from defamation actions, but Cooper’s suit argues that those privileges are not applicable in this case because Jacobi’s and Vissing’s comments were made “with actual malice or reckless disregard as to the truth.”
The state’s Code of Judicial Conduct generally bars judges from commenting on pending criminal investigations and cases.
Floyd County
Cooper sues Jacobi, Vissing for defamation
Judicial nominee’s husband says he’ll ‘take every dime I can’
- Floyd County
-
-
SWEET TREAT: Volunteers see the attraction of annual Starlight Strawberry Festival
-
Board chair: Parks district best solution for New Albany and Floyd County
Mayor Jeff Gahan’s veto of a new parks deal between the city and county was upheld earlier this month by the New Albany City Council. While the Floyd County Council agreed to still pay an additional $100,000 toward the parks department for the remainder of the year, the city and county remain under a prior agreement that led to funding discrepancies in the past.
-
THE 'V' WORD: SUB: Prosser Career Education Center moves away from stigma of ‘vocational’ school
- TARC sets Memorial Day and Kennedy Bridge route changes
-
Vietnam veteran receives medals 46 years after active duty ends
-
Pence talks bridges, jobs during Southern Indiana swing
“I think everyone senses with the recent bridges agreement, the potential for extraordinary growth,” said Mike Pence, a U.S. House member who is seeking to replace Gov. Mitch Daniels and retain the gubernatorial seat for the Republican Party.
-
Delaware woman dies in I-65 crash
-
Collingsworth Family to perform at Silver Heights Retreat Center in New Albany
The Collingsworth Family will be making a return trip to the Silver Heights Retreat and Camp Center in New Albany on Thursday, June 7.
-
Top Gun showing Saturday at the New Albany riverfront
In honor of Memorial Day, the city of New Albany will show the movie “Top Gun” on its new 40-foot screen at the Riverfront Amphitheater Saturday.
-
Organizers say lead contamination won’t hinder community garden in New Albany
Organizers said Wednesday they will proceed with a community garden despite lead contamination being discovered on the Culbertson Avenue site.
- More Floyd County Headlines
-


