New Albany City Councilwoman Diane McCartin-Benedetti didn’t have much to say Monday following her weekend arrest for operating while intoxicated by refusal. However, she said her story will be told at a later date.
“I’m innocent and the facts will be forthcoming,” McCartin-Benedetti told The Tribune.
She declined to answer any questions or offer further explanation at this time.
McCartin-Benedetti, who represents New Albany’s fifth district, was pulled over by an Indiana State Police trooper at 2:30 a.m. Saturday on Spring Street in New Albany for exceeding the speed limit, ISP Sgt. Jerry Goodin said.
Goodin said the councilwoman was taken to the Floyd County Jail without incident.
McCartin-Benedetti was released on recognizance from jail at 10:44 a.m. on Saturday by Floyd County Superior Court No. 2 Judge Glenn Hancock.
Goodin said being charged with OWI by refusal could indicate that McCartin-Benedetti refused a breathalyzer, but Goodin said he did not have enough information about the case to confirm that.
The majority of people arrested for OWI either have to bond out or go before the judge. Two of the 11 people arrested for OWI over the weekend were released by Hancock. The judge said he usually receives two or three calls each weekend requesting to have someone charged with OWI released from jail.
“It’s no different on this (case) than any other one,” Hancock said. “If it’s someone I have some knowledge of or if an attorney has entered on the case, they’re released after their burn-off period.”
Hancock said that when contacted about an inmate, he calls the jail to find out the circumstances of the arrest. If someone is arrested for refusal, they must take a portable breathalyzer test at the jail before being released, Hancock said.
Council President Dan Coffey said he does not condone McCartin-Benedetti’s action, but he does not expect the council will take any action against her because it has no policing authority.
“I hate to see anybody in a difficult situation, but the bottom line is we all make mistakes,” Coffey said. “Sometimes it actually ends up making us a better person.”
Coffey said McCartin-Benedetti’s arrest underscores a growing problem in New Albany.
“If you look at all the development downtown, it’s all been alcohol establishments,” Coffey said. “Downtown is just saturated with them.”
McCartin-Benedetti is scheduled for an initial hearing next Monday. A court clerk said charges usually are not filed until a day or two before the initial hearing.
Floyd County
New Albany councilwoman says ‘I’m innocent’
Diane McCartin-Benedetti arrested for DUI
- Floyd County
-
- TARC sets Memorial Day and Kennedy Bridge route changes
-
Vietnam veteran receives medals 46 years after active duty ends
-
Pence talks bridges, jobs during Southern Indiana swing
“I think everyone senses with the recent bridges agreement, the potential for extraordinary growth,” said Mike Pence, a U.S. House member who is seeking to replace Gov. Mitch Daniels and retain the gubernatorial seat for the Republican Party.
-
Delaware woman dies in I-65 crash
-
Collingsworth Family to perform at Silver Heights Retreat Center in New Albany
The Collingsworth Family will be making a return trip to the Silver Heights Retreat and Camp Center in New Albany on Thursday, June 7.
-
Top Gun showing Saturday at the New Albany riverfront
In honor of Memorial Day, the city of New Albany will show the movie “Top Gun” on its new 40-foot screen at the Riverfront Amphitheater Saturday.
-
Organizers say lead contamination won’t hinder community garden in New Albany
Organizers said Wednesday they will proceed with a community garden despite lead contamination being discovered on the Culbertson Avenue site.
-
Gregg, Simpson tout bi-partisanship during New Albany stop
They strolled side by side down the stairs leading to the New Albany Riverfront Amphitheater Wednesday, and when they took the stage, Democratic Gubernatorial candidate John Gregg and his running mate, Vi Simpson, talked about how their differences can strengthen Indiana.
-
Gibson faces death penalty
“To seek the death penalty is a decision not to be taken lightly,” Henderson said. “But the nature of these crimes, what we have accused Mr. Gibson of here, if these two crimes are not cause for the death penalty, then I don’t know what could be considered.”
-
River View gets a new option
As for progress, Bobo said he met with two banks Tuesday prior to the meeting. He added there’s been interest in financing the project from national lenders including U.S. Bank.
Additionally, Bobo said his team has meet with national investors as another source to fund the project and believes Mainland Properties could soon gain financial partners for River View. - More Floyd County Headlines


