The Indianapolis Museum of Art is teaming with bookstores, publishers and the ACLU of Indiana to sue over a new law that will require retailers to register with the state and pay a fee if they want to sell sexually explicit material.
Their complaint names every county prosecutor in Indiana and aims to stop the law from going into effect July 1. The law calls for retailers to register with the Indiana secretary of state.
State Rep. Terry Goodin, D-Crothersville, wrote the law to stop companies from deceiving communities with weak zoning laws to set up pornography stores. But the plaintiffs worry that it's too loosely defined and could crimp First Amendment rights, which include free speech and freedom of the press.
"We're talking about a law that has very broad and very vague and — we would contend — very unconstitutional restrictions and burdens," said Ken Falk, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana. "To the best of my knowledge, there is no similar law in the United States."
Goodin points to pornography vendors that pop up along interstate exits as the impetus for the law, which passed through the Indiana General Assembly earlier this year. He said a company told one southern Indiana community along Interstate 65 it planned to operate a truck stop gas station but then opened a porn store.
"Those folks are being deceived by these companies that are coming in. It's just not fair," Goodin said.
He noted that the law doesn't stop a business from selling pornography. It just requires the retailer to declare its intention to the community.
"This is all about local control, and giving those people at the local level the opportunity to decide whether they want those types of businesses in their area," he said.
If the law targets those businesses, then it should be written more narrowly to reflect that, said Maxwell Anderson, the art museum's CEO. The museum store sells art history books, and he noted that nudity plays a prominent role in the history of creativity.
"We don't want to start having to examine our book store and think about contents of our shelves in the way that this law requires," he said.
The lawsuit also cites another plaintiff, the Indianapolis store Big Hat Books, as an example of a business that could be harmed. It sells no material defined as obscene under state law, but it does sell literature with content that might be deemed harmful to minors.
It also earns more than half its revenue from children's literature, and that business may dissolve if the independent book store is "labeled as a purveyor of sexually explicit materials," the complaint states.
But Goodin said court rulings have shown there's no gray area when it comes to defining pornography.
"Individuals, corporations, companies know whether or not they're selling pornography," he said. "There's no question about that."
The notion that the law infringes on First Amendment rights is "absolutely ridiculous," he said.
"I think the folks who feel this way are being deceived by the pornography industry," he said. "It's unfortunate."
The lawsuit was filed Wednesday in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana. Other plaintiffs named include the Association of American Publishers Inc. and the National Association of Recording Merchandisers.
Recent Local News
ACLU suit targets new Ind. law on sexually explicit material
- Recent Local News
-
-
Dancing
-
In the doghouse
-
First Savings buys bank branches
The move will increase First Savings’ market share in Harrison County to about 31 percent and up the bank’s presence in Floyd County.
-
Forum helps Hispanic parents stay involved with education
Angelica Perez, family services adviser for Head Start, said it is important for children to learn English at a young age. She has seen the Hispanic population in Clark County grow and said there is an increased need for English Second Language programs.
-
Free falling: CCE demolishes former New Albany business at no charge
-
Floyd judge named semifinalist for Indiana Supreme Court
Granger, 42, said she decided to apply after discussions with her family and close friends.
“I care enormously about my judicial service, and I want to expand my work statewide,” she said. -
Indiana granted No Child Left Behind waiver
As the deadline approaches, more schools are failing to meet requirements under the law, with nearly half not doing so last year, according to the Center on Education Policy.
-
Democrats downsize: Clark County Democrats want to remove five precinct committee people for supporting candidates outside party
DeArk also said he never received a letter that said he may be removed as a precinct committeeman.
“As a matter of practice, I do not accept certified mail,” he said. -
Paying their fair share?
John Gilkey, president of the town council, said when Knott initially shared the information with him a few weeks ago, he was surprised to learn some residents weren’t paying any taxes.
- News and Tribune briefs for Feb. 9, 2012
-
Daniels visits Jeff to sign book, talk right-to-work
-
Single father graduates from Family Drug Court
Carmichael said the carrot and stick in Drug Court is not going back to prison. In the Family Treatment Drug Court, the motivation is to get their kids back. The participants have pending Child in Need of Services (CHINS) cases.
-
Neace Lukens acquires Jenkins Insurance of Sellersburg
Jenkins Insurance principal Mike Jenkins will join the Neace Lukens’ New Albany office, where he’ll focus on his current employee benefit clients and expanding service and product platforms for the company.
-
Some lawmakers want you to cruise in for Sunday commerce
The current ban on motorcycle sales is a remnant of Indiana’s old “blue laws” that prohibited various activities on Sundays. The legislature has been slowly chipping away at them.
-
Court of appeals hears Messer appeal
Counseled by attorney Bart Betteau, the basis of Messer’s appeal was that his words were constitutionally-protected free speech. But Special Judge Roger Duvall upheld the merit commission’s decision in 2011.
- More Recent Local News Headlines
-
