INDIANAPOLIS — Gov. Mitch Daniels says Indiana’s schools are “among America’s luckiest” since they have so far avoided cuts during the recession.
But only some Indiana schools would find four-leaf clovers under Daniels’ budget proposal.
Suburban schools with booming enrollments would see funding increases, while urban and rural school districts that are losing students would see decreases. Whether that approach is a fair way to distribute money is at the heart of partisan squabbles dominating budget talks as lawmakers prepare to start a special session Thursday.
But Democrats and Republicans are also arguing about the school funding numbers themselves.
The Republican governor says his two-year budget would give schools an average funding increase of 2 percent in each of the next two years, and more than 70 percent of traditional public schools would see an increase from 2009 to 2011. But Daniels’ budget relies heavily on federal stimulus money to provide those increases. That money — around $400 million — will run out in two years.
Democrats say Daniels’ numbers aren’t accurate and argue stimulus money shouldn’t be considered school funding because it should only be used on one-time expenditures.
When stimulus money isn’t factored in, 58 percent of Indiana’s traditional public school districts would lose money from 2009 to 2011, according to an Associated Press analysis of school funding numbers provided by the Daniels administration. Those figures do not include charter schools.
Daniels and other Republicans say it makes sense for schools to receive less money if they are losing students because they don’t need as many teachers and administrators.
“The money follows the child,” said Rep. Jeff Espich, R-Uniondale. “There are winners and losers.”
The losers aren’t happy.
The state’s largest district, Indianapolis Public Schools, warns that steep cuts could send it into a “death spiral” as more parents flee to the suburbs with their children, leaving shuttered schools and out-of-work teachers in their wake.
The district of 34,000 students is expected to lose nearly 2,000 students in each of the next two years. Under Daniels’ formula, IPS would lose nearly 11 percent of its funding from 2009 to 2011. When stimulus money is factored in, the district would see a cut of about 4 percent.
Superintendent Eugene White, who has made major changes at IPS in an effort to turn the district around, said cuts proposed under Daniels’ budget would be massive. The district has already laid off 300 teachers and closed several schools.
“This would be devastating to the Indianapolis Public Schools,” White said. “Quite frankly, we have come too far to rebuild a district devastated by this.”
House Speaker Patrick Bauer, D-South Bend, noted that Daniels eliminated part of the school funding formula that helped soften the blow of enrollment declines over time. He said the proposed cuts were too deep.
“You shouldn’t just fall off a cliff,” Bauer said.
The winners under Daniels’ plan would be fast-growing districts like Hamilton Southeastern Schools in the Indianapolis suburb of Fishers. That district would see a nearly 11 percent increase from 2009 to 2011, not counting stimulus money.
Finding a fair way to divvy up limited resources will be a challenge as lawmakers meet in a special session to hammer out a new budget before the current one expires June 30. Democrats who control the House say they will start meeting Tuesday to craft their own budget — one that won’t penalize shrinking schools as harshly.
“Basically, we’re trying to cause no harm,” Bauer said.
Recent Local News
Daniels’ budget would help suburban schools
- Recent Local News
-
-
New Albany City Council will be asked to clarify audit issue over sewer rates
Several members from the audience also questioned other financial matters of the city, and whether the council was aware that Gibson received health insurance as city attorney under England though it had been stated by the previous administration his contract did not include medical benefits.
-
River Ridge moves forward with development plans
No sale has been finalized on either piece of land, as River Ridge owns the 16-acre parcel, and the adjacent 54-acre tract is owned by Crossdock Development, a Louisville-based company that specializes in developing properties on the order of millions of square feet.
- News and Tribune briefs for Feb. 10, 2012
-
Town has no cure for ailing medical center
-
Dancing
-
In the doghouse
-
First Savings buys bank branches
The move will increase First Savings’ market share in Harrison County to about 31 percent and up the bank’s presence in Floyd County.
-
Forum helps Hispanic parents stay involved with education
Angelica Perez, family services adviser for Head Start, said it is important for children to learn English at a young age. She has seen the Hispanic population in Clark County grow and said there is an increased need for English Second Language programs.
-
Free falling: CCE demolishes former New Albany business at no charge
-
Floyd judge named semifinalist for Indiana Supreme Court
Granger, 42, said she decided to apply after discussions with her family and close friends.
“I care enormously about my judicial service, and I want to expand my work statewide,” she said. -
Indiana granted No Child Left Behind waiver
As the deadline approaches, more schools are failing to meet requirements under the law, with nearly half not doing so last year, according to the Center on Education Policy.
-
Democrats downsize: Clark County Democrats want to remove five precinct committee people for supporting candidates outside party
DeArk also said he never received a letter that said he may be removed as a precinct committeeman.
“As a matter of practice, I do not accept certified mail,” he said. -
Paying their fair share?
John Gilkey, president of the town council, said when Knott initially shared the information with him a few weeks ago, he was surprised to learn some residents weren’t paying any taxes.
- News and Tribune briefs for Feb. 9, 2012
-
Daniels visits Jeff to sign book, talk right-to-work
- More Recent Local News Headlines
-
New Albany City Council will be asked to clarify audit issue over sewer rates
