JEFFERSONVILLE —
Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller was in Southern Indiana on Thursday to discuss why he has joined a lawsuit challenging the recently signed health care reform bill.
“The reason I’ve decided to join [the suit] ... I’d announced even before the bill was passed that it had constitutional questions,” Zoeller said. “That really in the best interest of everybody — whether you support the legislation or whether you are worried about what it does — regardless, I think everybody needs some resolution to the constitutional questions that are raised.”
The seed of the challenge, at least for Indiana, dates back to January when Zoeller prepared a 55-page report on legal issues at the behest of Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind. The crux of the argument is the imposition of mandating health care coverage.
“We raised both [of] the questions about the constitutional reach of the federal government,” Zoeller, a Southern Indiana native, said. “Both in terms of an individual mandate, which now would require every citizen of the United States to purchase, for the first time ... a private product.”
The individual mandate, according to Zoeller, is in violation of the United States Commerce Clause, which is Article 1 of the U.S. Constitution.
PURCHASE PLAN
The Commerce Clause allows the federal government “to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states” and is often a legal argument brought to the forefront when a struggle is mentioned between federal and state power.
“It is true that over the years, the federal government has more and more authority breathed into their role under the commerce clause,” he said.
While constitutionality questions have been raised over the mandated purchase of health care, the original concept of a public-option plan would have been a government-run program and avoided this type of legal challenge.
“It’s unlike Medicaid, which is a federal program that everybody is required to be a part of,” Zoeller said of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. “But this would really require people to go out an purchase something, which is unprecedented.”
No Supreme Court decision has been made on whether or not the federal government can mandate that individuals buy the health insurance.
“Here there is no activity ... you’re actually regulating inactivity,” Zoeller said. “Just the mere fact that you live in a state is now going to be considered under the federal role the activity that is part of the [commerce]. I don’t think the federal government has the authority to regulate, really, just the fact that you are alive.”
INITIAL IMPACT
For the time being, the impact for Hoosiers relying on Medicare, Medicaid or the new health care legislation is expected to be minimal. It is believed that the hold placed on the Healthy Indiana Program will continue and Medicare and Medicaid provisions will move forward as expected, for now.
“For the most part, you won’t see a lot of changes,” Zoeller said.
No injunction was filed to halt the early stages of the health care bill from going into effect.
“Frankly, most of the bill will not take effect until 2014.”
In the meantime, Indiana and the 13 states it joined in the lawsuit will wait for the case to reach the Supreme Court, and it is believed that more states will join.
Zoeller did not offer which states will likely be added to the suit.
PLAYING POLITICS
Another issue that is fueling the suit that Indiana will join is purely political.
No Republicans voted for the passage of the health care legislation in either the House of Representatives or the Senate and 13 of the 14 attorneys general involved in the suit are Republicans, including Zoeller.
“The appearance that the attorneys general are bringing a claim against the new bill really is seen as political, but in fact I think it’s a healthy part of the process,” Zoeller said. “You still have to see whether the federal government has this authority for the individual mandate and the new requirements that mandate obligations by the state.”
But Zoeller insists that the attorneys involved are largely apolitical.
“People should not be seeing the challenge by the attorneys general as saying we are against health care reform,” Zoeller said. “It really goes to the heart of it, which is the question of federal authority versus state authority and individual rights.”
The other states that have entered in the suit are: South Carolina, Nebraska, Texas, Michigan, Utah, Pennsylvania, Alabama, South Dakota, Idaho, Washington, Colorado, Florida and Louisiana.
Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum, a Republican running for governor, filed the initial suit in Florida’s U.S. District Court.
Recent Local News
Related Photos
Discussion
Indiana AG answers questions on health bill challenge
Greg Zoeller says making people buy a private service is unconstitutional
- Recent Local News
-
-
New Albany, Jeffersonville celebrate Armed Forces Day
While a group of motorcycle riders, many of whom are veterans, took to the streets of New Albany to mark Armed Forces Day, a collection of groups offering assistance to former members of the military hosted a Stand Down event in Jeffersonville.
-
Local and state graduation rates see a rise for 2012
A second round of graduation rates for 2012 from the state will please some local districts while making others wish the changes were never made.
-
Legislature had little taste for alcohol bills
When it comes to alcohol, the 2013 legislative session may be marked more by what it didn’t do to boost booze sales than what it did.
-
Debate over state's alcohol laws continue
I’m not much a drinker, so I haven’t spent much time thinking about how Indiana’s alcohol laws personally impact me, but that changed last fall when my daughter got married.
-
Henryville Playground Built In One Day
-
Emergency officials stage bus wreck, gas spill at FCHS
A school bus had turned over after being struck by a gas tanker, and as the truck leaked chemicals, emergency crews rushed in to try and rescue the kids who were trapped inside.
Thankfully Friday’s crash scene was only a simulation, but for Floyd County emergency officials, it was an important test to prepare them for a real life scenario. -
Fun Faces At Clarksville Field Day
-
35th annual Starlight Strawberry Festival May 25
When Joe Huber and Daisy Book were looking for a way to honor local strawberry farmers in the area, they probably had no idea that 35 years later, their idea would attract nearly 10,000 visitors each year.
But that is exactly what organizers are expecting on Saturday, May 25, at the 35th annual Strawberry Festival held at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church in Starlight. -
Rinpoche’s journey to Indiana remarkable
Considering his tumultuous past, Arjia Rinpoche still smiles a lot. During a talk he gave Thursday at a Louisville’s Festival of Faiths presentation to celebrate the arrival of the Dalai Lama, the Buddhist monk grinned and chuckled as he told the tale of his remarkable life.
-
Floyd County Nutrition Coalition hands out 1,000 tomato plants
The organization recently handed out 1,000 free tomato plants in the community, as several groups participated in the effort including HOPE Southern Indiana, Floyd Memorial Hospital and Health Services and the Floyd County Health Department.
- INDOT to close lane of I-65 at 52-mile marker for repairs
- BRIEFS: May 18-19, 2013
-
“Caution Light’ the economic forecast for rest of year in Southern Indiana
Southern Indiana has made progress since the employment dip at the depths of the latest recession, but there’s still some catching up to do, Indiana University Southeast economic expert Uric Dufrene said Friday.
-
“Caution Light’ the economic forecast for rest of year in Southern Indiana
Southern Indiana has made progress since the employment dip at the depths of the latest recession, but there’s still some catching up to do, Indiana University Southeast economic expert Uric Dufrene said Friday.
-
POLICE: New Albany mother killed two children, then herself
New Albany Police Chief Sherri Knight said severe mental illness is what led to New Albany resident Jaime Clutter to drown her two children, then herself, in Falling Run Creek on March 13. The bodies were found where the creek runs through Binford Park.
- More Recent Local News Headlines
-
