Court: No right to resist unlawful police entry

Discussion

May 13, 2011

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Associated Press Fri May 13, 2011, 07:30 PM EDT

INDIANAPOLIS — People have no right to resist if police officers illegally enter their home, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled in a decision that overturns centuries of common law.

The court issued its 3-2 ruling on Thursday, contending that allowing residents to resist officers who enter their homes without any right would increase the risk of violent confrontation. If police enter a home illegally, the courts are the proper place to protest it, Justice Steven David said.

“We believe ... a right to resist an unlawful police entry into a home is against public policy and is incompatible with modern Fourth Amendment jurisprudence,” David said. “We also find that allowing resistance unnecessarily escalates the level of violence and therefore the risk of injuries to all parties involved without preventing the arrest.”

Justices Robert Rucker and Brent Dickson strongly dissented, saying the ruling runs afoul of the U.S. Constitution’s Fourth Amendment against unreasonable search and seizure, The Times of Munster reported.

“In my view the majority sweeps with far too broad a brush by essentially telling Indiana citizens that government agents may now enter their homes illegally — that is, without the necessity of a warrant, consent or exigent circumstances,” Rucker said.

Both dissenting justices suggested they would have supported the ruling if the court had limited its scope to stripping the right to resist officers who enter homes illegally in cases where they suspect domestic violence is being committed.

But Dickson said, “The wholesale abrogation of the historic right of a person to reasonably resist unlawful police entry into his dwelling is unwarranted and unnecessarily broad.”

The court’s decision stemmed from a Vanderburgh County case in which a man yelled at police and blocked them from entering his apartment to investigate a domestic disturbance. The man shoved a police officer who entered anyway and was shocked with a stun gun and arrested.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Police & Fire News

ISP arrests five at Clark County roadblock
May 24, 2012
Gibson faces death penalty
“To seek the death penalty is a decision not to be taken lightly,” Henderson said. “But the nature of these crimes, what we have accused Mr. Gibson of here, if these two crimes are not cause for the death penalty, then I don’t know what could be considered.”

May 23, 2012 1 Photo
FBI raids Jeffersonville auto shop, other property
May 22, 2012 1 Photo
Jeffersonville budget cuts move forward
The action is not final, as officially the council has only approved a resolution instructing the city’s financial officer to advertise the cuts.

May 22, 2012 1 Photo
New Albany man arrested for burglary, assault
The man who lived in the apartment said a Ford Mustang had been vandalized at the apartment complex earlier but that he had nothing to do with it.

May 21, 2012
Three people face meth charges
May 18, 2012
NAPD searches Monroe County for human remains
May 18, 2012 1 Photo
Area officers learn ways to deal with mentally ill
Jeffersonville Police Patrolman Chris Martin said he deals with mentally ill people on a daily basis.
“I thought it’d be good to better understand the mentally ill. I know it will help me on the streets when I’m dealing with them,” he said.

May 18, 2012 1 Photo
Woman faces multiple felonies after traffic stop
Further investigation revealed Ward was possessing fraudulent credit cards with the name Skylar Jones on them.

May 17, 2012
Jeffersonville man sentenced to 70 years for molestation
Reese was accused of having oral sex with a then 12-year-old girl that he lived with in Palmyra, in Harrison County.

May 16, 2012
More Police & Fire News Headlines

Police & Fire News

Search Results

Discussion

Court: No right to resist unlawful police entry

Site Map

Contact Us